I Hate the Dog I Adopted: A Candid Reflection on My Difficult Pet Journey

Adopting a dog is often considered to be a loving and compassionate act, as it allows individuals to provide a forever home to a furry companion in need. However, there are instances where the expectations and reality of dog ownership may not align, leading to feelings of dissatisfaction and frustration. In some unfortunate cases, individuals may find themselves regretting the decision to adopt a dog, harboring negative emotions towards their four-legged friend. While it’s undoubtedly disheartening to witness such sentiments, it’s necessary to acknowledge that dog ownership isn’t always a blissful experience and that these individuals deserve understanding and support. Examining the underlying reasons for their disaffection can shed light on the complexities of pet ownership and serve as an opportunity for growth and education. It’s crucial to approach this topic with empathy, open-mindedness, and an intention to find positive solutions that prioritize the well-being of both the owner and the dog.

Is It Wrong to Return an Adopted Dog?

Deciding whether or not to return an adopted dog can be an emotionally challenging experience. Many people may feel guilt or fear about giving their furry companion back to the shelter. However, it’s essential to remember that most animal shelters and rescue organizations have policies in place to address these situations. Their primary goal is to find the best possible home for the dog, and they understand that sometimes a match may not work out.

It’s crucial to give the dog time to adjust to their new home and provide them with proper training and support. However, if despite your best efforts, the dogs behavior or other circumstances make it impossible to provide them with a suitable environment, it’s in the best interest of all parties involved to consider returning the dog.

Being honest about your situation with the shelter is essential. They’re there to help and understand that sometimes things just don’t work out as expected. By communicating openly and honestly, you give them the opportunity to support you and find a better fit for both you and the dog. It isn’t a sign of failure or a reason for shame to return an adopted dog; it’s simply a recognition that the current situation might not be the best for everyone involved.

They may provide valuable insights and guidance on how to improve the situation. Remember, adopting a dog is a lifelong commitment, but sometimes circumstances change, and it’s essential to be adaptable and make the best decision for the well-being of the dog.

Shelters and rescue organizations are there to support these situations and understand that sometimes the initial adoption may not be a perfect match. By being honest and putting the dogs welfare first, you’re ensuring that they’ve the opportunity to find a more suitable forever home. It’s a difficult decision, but sometimes the best choice is to acknowledge that it isn’t working out and provide the dog with a chance at a better life.

The Emotional Impact of Returning an Adopted Dog and How to Cope With Feelings of Guilt or Shame

  • Recognize that feeling guilty or shameful is a normal response, but remind yourself that you made the best decision for both you and the dog.
  • Allow yourself to grieve the loss and acknowledge the emotions associated with returning the dog.
  • Reach out to a supportive friend or family member who can provide a listening ear and offer perspective.
  • Consider seeking professional help from a therapist or counselor who specializes in pet-related issues.
  • Find ways to honor the experience and the lessons learned from the adoption, such as volunteering at a local animal shelter or donating to a dog rescue organization.
  • Take time to reflect on what went wrong and learn from the experience to make more informed decisions in the future.
  • Remember that you aren’t alone in your feelings, and many others have gone through similar experiences.
  • Practice self-compassion and forgiveness, understanding that it’s okay to make mistakes and that we all have our limits and boundaries.
  • Consider adopting again in the future when you feel ready, keeping in mind the lessons learned from this experience.

While adopting a dog is often an exciting and fulfilling experience, there are occasions when returning a dog becomes necessary. Some common reasons why dogs are returned include unexpected financial burdens, human health issues, destructive behaviors such as soiling in the house or chewing furniture, and disobedience. It’s important to address these concerns and take the necessary steps to ensure the well-being of both the dog and it’s adoptive family.

What Is a Good Reason to Return a Adopted Dog?

Returning an adopted dog isn’t a decision to be taken lightly, as it can greatly impact the well-being of the animal. However, there are some valid reasons that might lead someone to make such a difficult choice. Unexpected costs can be a major factor, as caring for a dog involves financial responsibility for various expenses like food, medical bills, and grooming. Sometimes, unforeseen circumstances arise, leaving owners unable to meet these financial demands, which ultimately affects the dogs quality of life.

Destructive behaviors are another common reason for returned dogs. Some dogs, especially young or untrained ones, might engage in behaviors like soiling in the house or chewing furniture. While it’s essential to remember that these actions are often a result of inadequate training, some owners may lack the time, resources, or expertise required to address and correct these behaviors effectively. This frustration and inability to manage the dogs destructive tendencies can lead to considering returning the dog to the adoption agency.

Disobedience is yet another reason that might prompt someone to return their newly adopted dog. While it’s crucial to invest time and effort in training, some dogs may exhibit exceptionally stubborn or difficult-to-manage behaviors. In cases where inexperienced owners struggle to establish control or maintain a harmonious relationship, the dogs well-being and the owners peace of mind may be compromised. Under such circumstances, returning the dog to professionals who can provide necessary guidance and training might be deemed necessary.

Source: What’re some valid reasons to return a pet to the shelter?..


In reflecting upon my experience of adopting a dog, it’s become apparent that the initial negativity and frustration I harbored towards my canine companion stemmed from a lack of understanding and patience on my part. Through introspection and the recognition of our shared responsibility in building a harmonious relationship, I’ve learned the importance of compassion, commitment, and perseverance when navigating the world of pet ownership. Embracing the challenges that come with any new venture, including the adoption of a beloved pet, offers invaluable opportunities for personal growth and transformation. Ultimately, my journey has taught me that with an open mind and a willingness to adapt, true companionship and unconditional love can flourish, even in the most unexpected circumstances.

Scroll to Top