My Dog’s Relentless Desire for What the Other Dog Has

Dogs have a natural inclination to guard their resources, leading to a common and normal behavior known as resource guarding. This behavior manifests when dogs are unwilling to share valued resources, such as food, toys, or even the owner's attention. It isn’t uncommon to find a dog always wanting what the other dog has, as they’re pre-programmed to prioritize their own possessions. This natural instinct can be observed in pet dogs and is an inherent part of their canine nature.

Why Do My Dogs Share Bones?

Sharing bones is a common behavior observed in many dogs. It can be traced back to their evolutionary roots as pack animals, where individuals in a pack would often share resources to promote cohesion and cooperation. Just like in the wild, domesticated dogs have inherited this instinct to share and bond with their human family members.

By allowing others, including their owners, to partake in their prized possessions, dogs are displaying a sense of trust and respect. It’s their way of saying, “I trust you enough to share this valuable resource with you.”. This act of sharing helps to strengthen the bond between dogs and their owners.

Furthermore, dogs may use their owners lap as a support system while they chew on their bones. The physical closeness and warmth that the lap provides can offer a sense of security and comfort for dogs, making their chewing experience more enjoyable. It also allows them to be in close proximity to their owners, which dogs often find comforting and reassuring.

So the next time your furry friend offers you a bone, consider it a gesture of their affection and a way for them to show you just how deeply they care about you.

The Benefits of Sharing Bones With Dogs

Sharing bones with dogs can have several benefits. Firstly, it can enhance the bond between you and your furry friend. Dogs are natural chewers, and providing them with bones not only keeps them occupied, but it also strengthens their jaw muscles and promotes dental health. Additionally, chewing on bones can help alleviate stress and anxiety in dogs. However, it’s important to note that not all bones are safe for dogs. Ensure that you’re giving them appropriate bones, such as raw or uncooked ones, and monitor them while they chew to prevent any choking or digestive issues. If in doubt, consult with your veterinarian to ensure the safety and well-being of your beloved pet.

The bond between dogs extends beyond their interaction with humans. In a natural setting, dogs form a pack mentality and establish deep connections with their fellow canines. They not only protect one another but also engage in play and social activities. This reveals that dogs have the capability to form strong bonds with other dogs, creating a sense of companionship and camaraderie within their own kind.

Can Dogs Form Bonds With Other Dogs?

Can dogs form bonds with other dogs? Absolutely! Dogs are highly social animals that thrive on companionship, and this extends to their relationships with other canines. In fact, dogs are known to form deep emotional connections with their furry friends, often exhibiting a strong preference towards certain individuals within their social circle.

One key observation is the development of a pack mentality among dogs in a natural environment. Just like wolves, their wild ancestors, dogs have an innate instinct to form packs where they live, hunt, and protect together. Within these packs, dogs form strong bonds with each other, displaying loyalty and cooperation in various activities.

When dogs live and interact in a group setting, they engage in social rituals and behaviors that help foster these bonds. They engage in play sessions, share resources like food and toys, and engage in grooming behaviors. These activities not only strengthen their social ties but also serve as outlets for companionship and emotional fulfillment.

Moreover, dogs can display signs of separation distress when separated from their bonded companion. They may exhibit symptoms like restlessness, vocalization, and even changes in appetite. This further emphasizes the emotional attachment and unique bond they’ve formed with their fellow canine friend.

Observing dogs in their natural environment, we can witness the joy, loyalty, and affection they display towards their four-legged friends.

The Benefits of Dogs Forming Bonds With Other Dogs: Explore the Positive Effects That Forming Bonds With Other Dogs Can Have on a Dog’s Behavior, Well-Being, and Overall Quality of Life.

Building social bonds with other dogs can greatly benefit a dog’s behavior, well-being, and overall quality of life. When dogs form bonds with other dogs, they’re more likely to exhibit positive behaviors such as increased playfulness, improved social skills, and reduced anxiety or stress levels. These bonds provide dogs with opportunities for exercise, mental stimulation, and socialization, all of which contribute to their physical and emotional health. Additionally, interacting with other dogs allows them to learn important social cues and develop a sense of belonging within their canine community. Overall, the benefits of dogs forming bonds with other dogs result in happier, healthier, and more emotionally fulfilled pets.

This skill not only promotes socialization but also prevents possessive or aggressive behavior. So, should you make your dog share his toys? Let’s explore the benefits and considerations in the following sections.

Should I Make My Dog Share His Toys?

Sharing toys can also promote socialization and prevent possessive behavior in dogs.

To train a dog to share it’s toys, it’s important to start with a positive reinforcement approach. Begin by offering your dog a toy and allowing them to play with it for a short period of time. Then, calmly take the toy away and give it to another dog, if available. Reward your dog with praise and treats for relinquishing the toy willingly. Repeat this process, gradually increasing the duration of time your dog spends with the toy before it’s taken away.

Through positive reinforcement and exposure to other dogs, your dog can learn the importance of sharing and cooperation. Remember to always be patient, consistent, and understanding of your dogs unique personality and needs.

Source: Prevent resource guarding: Help your dog learn to share toys

It can be quite frustrating when one dog consistently steals toys from another in your household. However, there are steps you can take to remedy this behavior and restore harmony among your canine companions. Providing ample physical and mental exercise for both dogs is crucial, as it helps to release pent-up energy and reduce boredom. Additionally, ensuring that the stealing behavior isn’t rewarded and consistently rewarding good behavior can be effective in curbing this habit. Teaching your dog to swap things and using positive reinforcement techniques can also be helpful. Finally, knowing what to do when your dog takes something valuable or potentially harmful is important for their safety.

How Do I Get My Dog to Stop Stealing Toys From My Other Dog?

Getting your dog to stop stealing toys from your other dog requires a combination of training, patience, and understanding their underlying motivations. One important step is to provide both dogs with enough physical and mental exercise to prevent boredom and excess energy. This can help decrease their desire to engage in stealing behaviors.

Consistency is key when trying to change your dogs behavior. Always make sure to reward good behavior promptly and consistently. This can be done through verbal praise, treats, or other rewards that your dog finds motivating. By consistently rewarding positive behavior, your dog will start to understand which behaviors are desirable and which are not.

Teaching your dog to swap things is another helpful technique. This involves offering them a more valuable or interesting toy in exchange for the one they’ve stolen. By doing so, you reinforce the idea that they can still have fun and satisfaction without resorting to stealing.

Lastly, if your dog takes something that’s valuable or hazardous to their safety, it’s crucial to act quickly and calmly. Avoid chasing or physically punishing the dog, as this can worsen the situation or create fear. Instead, try to trade the item for a high-value treat or toy, and then redirect their focus onto something more appropriate. Consistent training and reinforcement will go a long way in helping your dog understand and overcome their stealing behavior.

Understanding the Motivations Behind Toy Stealing Behavior in Dogs

  • Exploring the concept of toy stealing behavior in dogs
  • Identifying the underlying motivations behind this behavior
  • Examining the role of territoriality and possessiveness in toy stealing
  • Considering the influence of social dynamics and hierarchy
  • Understanding the impact of breed traits on toy stealing behavior
  • Exploring the potential link between boredom and toy stealing
  • Examining the role of environmental enrichment in reducing toy stealing
  • Discussing training techniques to address toy stealing behavior
  • Highlighting the importance of socialization and positive reinforcement
  • Considering ethical implications and owner responsibilities

This can lead to possessive behavior, as the dog tries to guard it’s treasures to ensure it’s access to them. Understanding and addressing this possessiveness is crucial for a harmonious and safe relationship between dogs and their owners or other animals.

Do Dogs Get Possessive Over Bones?

This possessiveness can manifest in various ways, including growling, snapping, or even biting. It’s important for dog owners to understand that this behavior is rooted in the instinctual nature of dogs to protect what they perceive as their possessions. However, dog possessiveness can be managed and even eliminated through proper training and socialization.

To address possessive behavior over bones specifically, one can start by teaching the dog basic obedience commands such as “drop,” “leave it,” and “give.”. These commands can help establish a sense of control and authority for the owner, while also teaching the dog that relinquishing the bone isn’t a threat to their well-being.

Socialization is also crucial in reducing possessiveness. Exposing the dog to various people and animals during their formative years can help them develop a more relaxed attitude towards sharing resources. This can be done through supervised playdates or visits to dog parks where the dog can interact and learn to share space and toys with other animals.

Another helpful technique is to introduce positive reinforcement. For example, when the dog willingly gives up their bone upon command, they can be rewarded with treats, praise, or playtime. This positive association teaches the dog that relinquishing their possessions can lead to positive outcomes.

By providing a secure and well-structured environment for our furry friends, we can teach them to feel more comfortable sharing their valued resources.


It’s important for owners to understand that their dogs' desire to possess valued resources isn’t indicative of a negative personality or temperament. Rather, it’s a part of their genetic makeup and survival instincts. Ultimately, proper training, socialization, and positive reinforcement can help mitigate resource guarding tendencies, ensuring a harmonious coexistence between the dogs and their human companions.

Scroll to Top